• About WordPress
    • WordPress.org
    • Documentation
    • Learn WordPress
    • Support
    • Feedback
  • Log In
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • Contact us
  • Related Sites
    • InflationData.com
    • Financial Trend Forecaster
    • Your Family Finances
    • Elliott Wave University
    • Optio Money
  • About
    • Terms of Use
    • Disclaimer & Disclosure
    • Privacy Statement
  • Sitemap
    • 2009-2010 Posts
    • 2011 Posts

UnemploymentData.com

Your Source for Employment and Unemployment Data

Unemployment
  • Charts
    • Current Unemployment Rate Chart
    • Current Employment Rate (Chart and Data)
    • Current Employment vs Unemployment Chart
    • Historical Employment Data
    • Employment Population Ratio
    • Misery Index
  • Unemployment
    • Historical Unemployment Rate Tables
    • What Is U-6 Unemployment?
    • Unadjusted vs. Seasonally Adjusted U-3 Unemployment Rate
    • BLS vs. Gallup Unemployment Numbers
    • Current U-6 Unemployment Rate
    • What is the Labor Force Participation Rate?
    • What is the Real Unemployment Rate?
  • Employment
    • Current Employment Rate (Chart and Data)
    • Historical Employment Data
    • Contacting a Live Person at the State Employment Commission
      • How to Talk to a Live Person at the Virginia Unemployment Commission
      • Florida’s FLUID Unemployment Program
    • Benefits
      • Insurance
      • Retirement
    • Careers
    • Employment Costs
    • Experience
    • Government
    • Job Hunting
      • Interview
      • Resume
  • Find Articles
  • Education
    • Skills
  • General
    • Small Business
      • Outsourcing
    • Success
You are here: Home / Employment / Benefits / Would More Jobs Help Social Security?

Would More Jobs Help Social Security?

April 16, 2025 by Valerie Rhea Leave a Comment

Social Security Check
Image Created by Meta AI

The following article by Valerie Rhea originally appeared on Quora. Valerie is a thirty-something PhD economist, former military pilot, with a law degree.

Would More Jobs Help Social Security?

Yes, higher employment (and higher wages, by the way) results in more inflows to the Social Security system. In 2024, the SSA spent about $60 billion more than it took in via payroll taxes. If US payrolls increased by about $500 billion – that’s about 1.75% of GDP – then instead of operating at a deficit, Social Security would have approximately broken even.

To realize $500 billion in increased payrolls, roughly 6 million average-paying jobs would need to be added. If we forget about population growth for a moment, that means expanding the US workforce participation rate by about 4% would do the trick. That would take us to a workforce participation rate of about 66%—levels last seen during the Bush administration.

Unfortunately, keeping Social Security solvent becomes increasingly difficult to keep up with because of the country’s demographics. Right now, an estimated 2.4 workers pay into Social Security for every person receiving benefits, down from about five workers per beneficiary in 1960. By 2050, the ratio is expected to fall below two workers per beneficiary. Further, during any period of inflation, COLA adjustments and so on force the cost of benefits to grow rapidly. Although every little bit helps, America just isn’t likely to grow our workforce fast enough to keep up with longer lifespans.

When the Social Security program was first passed, the retirement age was 65 and the mean life expectancy in the US was 61. The average worker would pay into Social Security all of his working life but only receive benefits for a short time. Today, this is quite different…benefits can begin at any age from 62 on, and US life expectancies are about 80 years. The average participant in Social Security can thus receive benefits for 10–20 years in many cases.

So while higher employment levels help Social Security, alone, they will probably not be sufficient to keep the program solvent. Focusing on waste/fraud/abuse in the system is important too, and if we want to continue the program into the future (which is a separate debate…Social Security tends to be a bad deal for workers), we will need to look at a mix of administrative streamlining, tax increases, benefit cuts, or new investment options for the Social Security trusts that return better results than the current 2.2% earned by Social Security.

This last point is important. The average US union pension fund has returned about 7% since 1960. The average university endowment fund returned over 9% during that same timeframe. Social Security, because it is limited to investing in US Treasury debt exclusively, sees a relatively poor return by comparison. To illustrate the point, if the current Social Security trust could just realize 5% returns, the program would be solvent for the foreseeable future, and with some of the other improvements discussed here, there could even be funding to give retirees substantial benefit increases without bankrupting the system.

Further complicating the problem is our hyper-partisan politics. The last serious attempt to reform Social Security resulted in TV commercials showing Republican politicians literally pushing a wheelchair-bound Grandma off a cliff. Democrats haven’t offered a reform plan since the 1980s, and now, Republicans are so fearful of touching that “third rail of politics” that they don’t try either. I suppose both parties believe that when Social Security runs out of money to meet all its commitments in about eight years, they will be able to impose a more politically advantageous solution in the moment of crisis.

Saner minds need to prevail, but sadly, in our political climate, that seems nearly impossible.

Filed Under: Benefits Tagged With: jobs, Social Security

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

For security, use of Google's reCAPTCHA service is required which is subject to the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Search Site

Sponsored:

URGENT: These Stocks Stand Poised to Benefit from President Trump's Trade Wars!

As the Trump administration moves ahead with aggressive tariff policies on key imports, the mainstream media is scrambling.

This Free Report - which you can download now - reveals the names and ticker symbols of 5 Stock Poised to Benefit Most from President Trump's Tariff Wars.

Click Here to Download Your FREE Stock Report Now.

Recent Posts

  • April 2025 Employment / Unemployment Report
  • Would More Jobs Help Social Security?
  • March 2025- Employment / Unemployment Report
  • February 2025 Jobs Report
  • January 2025 BLS Employment Report

Resources

  • Bureau of Labor Statistics Current Population Survey Monthly survey of households conducted by the Bureau of Census for BLS. It provides data on the labor force, employment, unemployment, etc.
  • Capital Professional Services Providing web design and development and Internet marketing services
  • Elliott Wave University Using the Elliott Wave Principle to improve investment performance
  • Financial Trend Forecaster Featuring Moore Inflation Predictor, NYSE Rate of Change and NASDAQ Rate of change
  • InflationData.com Inflation calculators, databases, etc.
  • Intergalactic Web Designers Web design and development services
  • Your Family Finances

Articles by Category

Articles by Date

Disclaimer

At UnemploymentData.com we are not registered investment advisors and do not provide any individualized advice. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future performance and future accuracy and profitable results cannot be guaranteed.

Privacy & Terms of Use

Privacy Statement & Terms of Use

Do Not Sell My Information

Copyright © 2025 · News Pro on Capital Professional Services, LLC. All rights reserved · Log in